The Peer Review Process

When a paper arrives at a journal editorial office a few things can happen:

  • Editor reviews paper herself/himself.
  • Editor assigns to two Associate Editors (AEs Act as a Peer Reviewers)
  • What to look for?

    1)Appropriateness for the journal

  • Is the topic relevant to the journal?
  • Is the topic timely?
  • Is the topic significant?
  • Is the study unique? If so, How?

  • 2)What type of paper/research is it?

    If research, how is it structured?

  • Randomized, controlled, blinded Meta-analysis?
  • Retrospective?
  • Case series or single case

  • Editor/AEs (Peer Reviewers) look for:

    1)Did the author follow the instructions of the journal?

  • Correct Number of Authors?
  • Conflict of Interest/Disclosure Statement?
  • Copyright release signed?
  • Informed consent (if applicable)/Ethics considerations

  • 2)Is the article format correct?

  • Structured abstract?
  • Correct article format (Abstract, Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion, Conclusion, Refs?)
  • Are References in correct format?

  • AEs (Peer Reviewers) look for:

    1)Are the technical aspects correct?

  • Research Structure: Correctly described and performed?
  • Statistics: Correct analysis?, Accurate interpretation?, Clear presentation?

  • Editor/AEs (Peer Reviewers) look for:

    1)Technical aspects, continued Tables and Figures:

  • Accurate and clear structure, presentation, and presentation?
  • Do the numbers add up?
  • Are the data consistent with the body of the paper?

  • 2)Abstract & Body of paper:

  • Do number of patients, other data match?
  • Conclusions consistent?

  • Paper Rejection:
  • Most journals accept 30% or less

  • Review Process Flow Chart

    We have enclosed the Peer review process flow chart for public reference. Click Here for Download

    Creative Commons Licence
    Journal of Management and Science by JMS is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
    Based on a work at http://jms.nonolympictimes.org.
    Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at http://jms.nonolympictimes.org.
    .